Pogue Mahone Pub & Kitchen - Toronto

Irish Pub Fare, Pubs, Delivery Services
777 Bay Street, Toronto M5G 2B3., M4Y2M5, Canada
Dishes: 54
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Pogue Mahone Pub & K... 777 Bay Street, Toronto M5G 2B3., M4...
Phone
+14165983339
Reservation
Reservation request for Pogue Mahone Pub & K....

Menu

The restaurant from Toronto offers 54 different courses and drinks on the menu at an average price of CA$13.

Pogue Mahone Pub and Kitchen presents a mixed bag of experiences that leaves diners with varying impressions. While some patrons praise the hearty portions, delicious pub fare, and vibrant atmosphere, others highlight significant shortcomings in service and value. Reports of lost reservations and long wait times overshadow the positive aspects, casting doubt on management’s responsiveness. The appeal of outdoor seating and live music adds charm, though the environment can be too loud for intimate gatherings. With a diverse menu accommodating various diets, it may cater well to casual outings, but guests seeking a polished dining experience might want to look elsewhere.

Last update: 19.04.2025

Images

Pogue Mahone Pub & Kitchen inside Pogue Mahone Pub & Kitchen

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 2.3 / 5 from 3 reviews

Was User at Pogue Mahone Pub & Kitchen a mag?
Food at Pogue Mahone is delicious, were with a group of six and everyone was completely satisfied with our orders. Portions are of a good size, I had one of their burgers and fries and could barely eat it all. Sat on the outdoor patio overlooking the street and it was people watching while you eat, can't get better entertainment than that. View all feedback.

What User dislikes about Pogue Mahone Pub & Kitchen:
You know the saying... when a woman says something is fine... well... it's not :)Yes, I could have said it was ok but it's really not even that. The combination of bad service, terrible food (super soggy lettuce in the PP salad and burnt toast on the club sandwhich, which only came with two pieces of bread so can't be a "club") and warm white wine (in the Summer!!! on the patio!!!) can receive a ranking of "ok".For r... View all feedback.

blanda-cynthia
Cynthia 17.11.2017 - 07:11

Tourist Warning: During our trip to Toronto, my boyfriend and I stumbled upon this restaurant that caught our eye with its charming exterior.

edgardo-141
Edgardo 19.06.2020 - 09:38

I came to this restaurant with friends and was disappointed by the high prices. I paid $20 for a small turkey sandwich and fries, which I found to be extremely overpriced.

marina-antonenko
Марина 17.11.2017 - 07:11

This is my first two-star review. I didn't find anything particularly special about this restaurant and I most likely won't be returning.

You know the saying... when a woman says something is fine... well... it's not :)Yes, I could have said it was ok but it's really not even that. The combination of bad service, terrible food (super soggy lettuce in the PP salad and burnt toast on the club sandwhich, which only came with two pieces of bread so can't be a "club") and warm white wine (in the Summer!!! on the patio!!!) can receive a ranking of "ok".For reader clarification (and TripAdvisor rankings), OK=poor, FINE=terrible ;)

Food at Pogue Mahone is delicious, were with a group of six and everyone was completely satisfied with our orders. Portions are of a good size, I had one of their burgers and fries and could barely eat it all. Sat on the outdoor patio overlooking the street and it was people watching while you eat, can't get better entertainment than that.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.