Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback Was jackied at 42nd Street Oyster Bar Co. a mag?
This was our first time eating at 42nd Street Oyster Bar. Our server, David, was very very good. He had great recommendations and made the evening with friends very enjoyable. The food was also very good. My mahi was cooked perfectly. Will definitely return. View all feedback.
What BillM dislikes about 42nd Street Oyster Bar Co.:
Overall Disappointing... Again. Over the years, I've given 42nd Street multiple chances. Thinking maybe I just ordered the wrong selection, I always try something different. However, each time, the entrees are sub-par. This visit, 2 diners ordered the crab cakes and the other the Norfolk Crab. While one diners crab cakes were burnt both were bready and dry and while plentiful the Norfolk Crab lacked seasoning and fla... View all feedback.
42nd Street Oyster Bar is one of our favorite places to dine. Staff was very friendly and courteous. The food was amazing.
Great place, great food, Luke was a great waiter and made it a fun night. Depending on the night I would make a reservation. They had some great fish specials. The Apple pie with rum sauce was to die for. Thank you Mr H. for stopping by and saying hello. You have a great place and it shows.
It was our first time eating at this restaurant. Overall we are satisfied. The portions are huge and very filling. Will definitely be back
Food was incredibly salty, and not hot. Noise was really loud.
Go easy on the fried corn brought as a free appetiser if you want to eat a full meal. We should have done without starters each which meant we only had room to share a fish platter main. This was the best part of the meal: much tastier and healthier than our fried starters. Quite reasonably priced. Service very brisk but friendly.
Full Menu
Seafood Dishes
Starters & Tasters
Starters
Starters & Salads
Half Shell Selections*
Raw Bar
More information
QR-code link to the menu
