Pizzaiolo Primo - Pittsburgh

Italian, Pizza, Ice Cream
8 Market Square Pittsburgh, PA 15222, 15222-1703, United States
Dishes: 130
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Pizzaiolo Primo 8 Market Square Pittsburgh, PA 15222...
Phone
+14125755858
Reservation
Reservation request for Pizzaiolo Primo.

Menu

The menu of Pizzaiolo Primo from Pittsburgh contains about 130 different menus and drinks. On average you pay about $26.7 for a dish / drink.

Despite some mixed reviews, Pizzaiolo Primo seems to have its loyal fans. While some patrons were disappointed by the food quality and service, others raved about their fantastic experiences. The restaurant seems to have a cozy and fun atmosphere, perfect for both casual and special occasions. Many diners highlighted specific dishes they enjoyed, such as the fried zucchini appetizer and the chicken with morel sauce. Overall, opinions on Pizzaiolo Primo are varied, but it may be worth a visit to judge for yourself.

Last update: 17.04.2025

Images

Pizzaiolo Primo food Pizzaiolo Primo food Pizzaiolo Primo inside Pizzaiolo Primo food Pizzaiolo Primo inside Pizzaiolo Primo food Pizzaiolo Primo food Pizzaiolo Primo food Pizzaiolo Primo food Pizzaiolo Primo food

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 842 reviews

Was User at Pizzaiolo Primo a mag?
This was our first time dining at the restaurant since standards took effect. The staff exceeded expectations in keeping the safety of all guests in mind. Of course, the food was excellent. The seasonal salads are always a favorite of ours! We look forward to returning. View all feedback.

What User dislikes about Pizzaiolo Primo:
we come to the restaurant and find that it is closed. we were very disappointed that we had to find a place to eat. someone should have the opportunity to make reservations. View all feedback.

michelek
MicheleK 13.01.2024 - 01:36

The waitress was excellent. She was aware of my food allergy in advance and provided helpful recommendations for my meal choices. The food was delicious! The restaurant is conveniently located for anyone attending a show in the Pittsburgh theater district.

kathleens
KathleenS 13.01.2024 - 01:36

This is one of our go-to restaurants. However, the food disappointed us this time. The fettuccine was dry, and we had trouble getting our server's attention for water or other requests. We even had to ask for bread halfway through our meal. Overall, this visit did not live up to the wonderful experiences we have had here in the past.

rosemaryb
RosemaryB 13.01.2024 - 01:36

Fantastic New Years Eve dinner. It was busy, loud but not too loud, very fun, cozy atmosphere. The fried zucchini appetizer was one of the best we've had, the branzino fettuccine alfredo (the extra sausage was amazing) were perfect. Our server was adorable loved her. So glad we ended the year with Pizzaiolo Primo!

katlyn-marquardt
Katlyn 13.01.2024 - 01:36

Overall it was an okay experience. The server was friendly and helpful. The bartender was an absolute train wreck. They were out of a lot of bar and food items. The male manager did nothing to help the guests or staff. He stood behind the bar gossiping with the terrible bartender. The meatballs seemed to be pre-made, frozen out of the bag. They ran out of bread. The pasta was decent but bland. The pizza was phenomenal. For the quality of food, service and ambience, it wasn’t worth $200+ for two people. Based on this visit, I would not recommend and will not return.

garyg
GaryG 13.01.2024 - 01:36

So great that I’m hoping to bring many people there.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.