Pizzeria Sirenetta - New York

#17 - Vegetarian - New York, #38 - Kebab - New York, Italian
568 Amsterdam Avenue New York, NY 10024, United States
Dishes: 149
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Pizzeria Sirenetta 568 Amsterdam Avenue New York, NY 10...
Phone
+12127997401
Reservation
Reservation request for Pizzeria Sirenetta.

Menu

The menu of Pizzeria Sirenetta from New York contains about 149 different dishes and drinks. On average you pay about $18.1 for a dish / drink.

Sirenetta, formerly known as Sirenetta Pizzeria, has been receiving rave reviews from patrons for its diverse menu offerings. The beet salad and tuna dishes were highlighted as excellently prepared, with the tuna being perfectly medium-rare. The pizza was also praised for its delicious taste. While the kale salad and dessert received some mixed feedback, the overall dining experience was positive. The staff was commended for their excellent service, particularly Tarek who provided exceptional hospitality. Happy Hour specials were well-received, featuring great mini kale salads and tasty pizzas with a crispy thin crust. The Sunday brunch menu was also a hit, with standout dishes like ricotta pancakes and smoked salmon pizza. However, some customers noted issues with rushed service, such as being abruptly switched to a new server and feeling hurried through their meal. Despite these minor concerns, Sirenetta continues to impress guests with its outstanding food, lovely ambiance, and reasonable prices, making it a popular choice for many diners.

Last update: 09.07.2025

Images

Pizzeria Sirenetta food Pizzeria Sirenetta food Pizzeria Sirenetta food Pizzeria Sirenetta food Pizzeria Sirenetta drink Pizzeria Sirenetta food Pizzeria Sirenetta food Pizzeria Sirenetta inside Pizzeria Sirenetta food

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 2924 reviews

Was Emmet Stracke at Pizzeria Sirenetta a mag?
Reliable and good. The first courses are generally delicious, such as the fried artichokes, the octopus, and the mustard green salad. The shaved beet salad just misses: although the garnish and dressing are excellent, the beets are overly al dente. The pizza is always good. The crust is first rate. I'd like it if they offered more choices items one could add on if one wanted, but the options they do have are terrific... View all feedback.

What Keira Konopelski dislikes about Pizzeria Sirenetta:
Sirenetta (they 've dropped Pizzeria from the name) has become one of our go-to spots. When they changed the menu to add more diverse items, things really picked-up. On our most recent visit we had started with the beet salad and then had the tuna. Both dishes very nicely put together and the tuna was perfectly medium-rare. The pizza is very good too! View all feedback.

leslie37
Leslie 16.11.2017 - 07:15

Hit up this spot for the last hour of Happy Hour!! Looking for great pizza and even better pasta? LOOK NO FURTHER! No seriously, don't, I'm not kidding.

larue-rosenbaum
Larue 16.11.2017 - 07:15

Great great place Very nice ambience and fancy looking placeService was excellent, fast and waiter was very friendly.

lboyer
Rowena 16.11.2017 - 07:15

Loved the decorThe place was surrounded by white bricksThe bar area was nice We went in and were handed the pizza menu, which was fine with us.

ohara-marilie
Marilie 08.08.2017 - 10:02

The food and service were excellent. Well worth the drive to South River.

earlene-20
Earlene 20.06.2022 - 09:37

The food was very good. The seats are a bit tight, but the space is very nice. Would definitely eat there again.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.