Jacob's Pickles - New York

#11 - Order Sushi New York, #13 - Order Pizza New York, Cafés
Upper West Side & Central Park, 509 Amsterdam Ave, 10024, New York, United States
Dishes: 122
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Jacob's Pickles Upper West Side & Central Park, 509...
Phone
+12124705566
Reservation
Reservation request for Jacob's Pickles.

Menu

The menu of Jacob's Pickles from New York includes 122 menus. On average the menus or drinks on the menu cost approximately $13.0. You can view the categories on the menu below.

This restaurant on the Upper West Side is a family-friendly gem that goes above and beyond to accommodate guests of all ages, even those with logistical challenges like strollers and car seats. Despite a few mixed reviews regarding the greasiness of some dishes, the overall consensus is that the food is delicious and the portion sizes are generous. Whether you're looking for a great brunch spot or a fantastic dinner with fantastic service, this Southern food spot is a must-visit for anyone in the city. The cozy atmosphere, amazing cocktails, and use of pickles throughout the menu add to the comfort food experience that keeps customers coming back time and time again. Consider making a reservation, especially for outdoor dining, to ensure a pleasant visit to this New York favorite.

Last update: 10.06.2025

Images

Jacob's Pickles food Jacob's Pickles food Jacob's Pickles drink Jacob's Pickles food Jacob's Pickles drink Jacob's Pickles food Jacob's Pickles food Jacob's Pickles food Jacob's Pickles menu Jacob's Pickles food

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 25025 reviews

Was OpenTable Diner at Jacob's Pickles a mag?
Came here a few months back in October with a few of my girls for my sisters birthday. The food was AMAZING!! The portions were huge and the resturant itself was pretty. The food was so good we were craving it recently . My sister and I decided to go again . I was very dissapointed . The food wasnt as great as we remembered, it was average. Something changed. The fried chicken was barely crispy. Maybe we came on an o... View all feedback.

What Karina dislikes about Jacob's Pickles:
I came for their pancakes and I get these super thin, dry, hard, and no favor pancakes!!!!!!!!! The chicken had no syrup and was so dry. They went from serving THREE pancakes to TWO, still charging $22. Absolutely insane. There was no syrup on these and overall what a waste of time and money. I wanted to just walk away when I got my food. Our glass of water was served with this dirty price of white thing on the brim.... View all feedback.

brian-m-pilot9962
Brian 10.11.2023 - 22:52

When I cheat from my vegetarian diet, this Low Country Meatloaf is at the top of my list!

andrew-g-restaurant6
Andrew 10.11.2023 - 22:52

Everything was tasted good, but to call what I got Poutine was an affront to Canadians. Just call em cheese fries

anna-t-pilot71
Anna 10.11.2023 - 22:52

The fried pickles were not good at all and the Mac and cheese was greasy and had no flavor

dale-f-doctor1166
Dale 10.11.2023 - 22:52

So so so greasy. It was inedible. Shrimp Bacon Grits had so much grease, a layer floated on top of the grits. Fried pickles were smaller than shoestring fries. 95% breading. Like what happened to pickle quarters in fried pickles? Bf liked the patty Jacob's Patty Melt. Had to stop or I'd be running to the bathroom all night.

pemmerich
Dianna 06.12.2017 - 12:34

Yes, I just reviewed this place 2 days agoBut I didn't want to review the two experiences I had here in one review.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.