Rookie's Cookies - New Albany

#40 - Seafood - New Albany, American, Delivery
310 Pearl StIN 47150, New Albany, United States
Dishes: 64
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Rookie's Cookies 310 Pearl StIN 47150, New Albany, Un...
Phone
+18129488858
Reservation
Reservation request for Rookie's Cookies.

Menu

The menu of Rookie's Cookies from New Albany includes 64 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $11.5. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Rookies Cookies and Cakes has received rave reviews for their delicious treats, stunning cakes, and exceptional service. Customers have praised the moist and flavorful cakes, with standout flavors like Italian cream and Lemon Blueberry Swirl. Reviewers have also highlighted the beautiful cake decorations and the ease of working with the team for special events like weddings and birthdays. Personalized orders, such as volleyball cookies for a team celebration, were executed flawlessly. Overall, Rookies Cookies and Cakes is a local gem that consistently delivers high-quality products and receives glowing recommendations from satisfied customers.

Last update: 26.05.2025

Images

Rookie's Cookies food Rookie's Cookies food Rookie's Cookies logo Rookie's Cookies food Rookie's Cookies inside Rookie's Cookies outside Rookie's Cookies menu Rookie's Cookies menu Rookie's Cookies outside Rookie's Cookies food

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 4.8 / 5 from 231 reviews

Was User at Rookie's Cookies a mag?
Rookies Cookies and Cakes made the cake for our daughter's wedding. I had a lot of people telling me it was the best cake they've ever eaten! I was also pleased that Shara (the entrepreneur) was ready to deliver the cake and set it up for me at the venue! Thank you for good service! View all feedback.

a-msaone-harris
A 21.09.2023 - 15:40

I want to thank you all for surpassing our expectations. We ordered a 2-tier cake with Lemon cake with Blueberry Swirl on top and Red Velvet cake on the bottom. The cake decoration was stunning. The cakes were flavorful and moist. I highly recommend them for your cake needs.

ashley-klink
Ashley 21.09.2023 - 15:40

I couldn't have asked for a better Bachelorette and Bridal Shower Cake! They were super easy to work with and made the most beautiful cakes for my special events!

taylor-mae-welch
Taylor 21.09.2023 - 15:40

I got my wedding cake from Rookies Cookies and it was AMAZING!! High recommend this bakery and they were easy to work with!

kayla-klein-hackett
Kayla 21.09.2023 - 15:40

Shera and team did an AMAZING job on our wedding cake, grooms cake, and the cookies at our wedding this past weekend! They executed our vision to perfection and we received several compliments on how great the cakes/cookies looked and tasted. Thanks to you all for helping make our dreams become reality!

terry-lynch
Terry 21.09.2023 - 15:40

Love Rookies Cookies and the best Cherry pies ever!!!!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.