Grey Lady - Montauk Reviews (212)

So that you don't dive naively into a new culinary adventure, Menulist has compiled all the ratings for Grey Lady - Montauk from various websites, so you can get a transparent picture. So far there are 212 ratings found on 2 pages. On average, Grey Lady - Montauk was rated 3.9. This means that the vast majority of its guests was satisfied with its service. Help our community find the best spots and submit a review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

3.9 out of 5

Very good | 212 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Grey Lady - Montauk from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (3.9 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in MONTAUK.

chillaxin

20.02.2024 - 04:21

Seafood pasta was awful.

amcd973

20.02.2024 - 04:21

Terrible experience here. We were told we needed to do a prefix menu. Within 30 minutes of sitting down, before we even had the chance to finish our appetizers...

monique

20.02.2024 - 04:21

We made a 630 reservation and we show up and the place was completely empty. I mean like no other human was there besides my family. They were blasting music fo...

kamorim-1

20.02.2024 - 04:21

We were looking for more low key restaurant iur first night in Montauk and the Grey Lady fit the bill. The outside space was nice with the high tables. The food...

sooz

20.02.2024 - 04:21

Caters to a very young crowd. Was early in the season, had dinner on a rainy night over MD weekend. Even half full, noise level was pretty high, can only imagin...

Last update : 20.02.2024

You need to register or login to leave feedback.

Good Rated Restaurants near MONTAUK

Muse At The End

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: MONTAUK, 41 S Euclid AvenueNY 11954, MONTAUK, United States

"Dinner was very good. The hostess was a bit rude but the waitress made up for it. Scampi and Greek chicken were great. Bread pudding too!"

##2 Pizza in MONTAUK

Details

#2 Pizza in MONTAUK

Hooked

4.6

City: MONTAUK, 34 S Etna Ave, MONTAUK, United States

"We ordered Mahi and Greens and a Mahi sandwich, also lobster bisque. The fish was cooked for perfection and delicious! Salad and also fresh and tasty. My husband also loved the bisque. Very friendly owner!"

##2 Seafood in MONTAUK

Details

#2 Seafood in MONTAUK American

Wölffer Kitchen Amagansett

4.3

City: Amagansett (near MONTAUK), 4 Amagansett Square Dr, 11930, United States

"Food was good but overpriced. Main dishes are big portion and drinks are great. Staffs are extremely friendly. Patio tables are much more warmer than regular outdoor seats with heaters."

##8 Vegetarian in Amaganse...

Details

#8 Vegetarian in Amagansett Pizza

Harvest On Fort Pond

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: Town of East Hampton (near MONTAUK), 11 South Emery Street, Town Of East Hampton, 11954, United States Of America, Town of East Hampton

"It's been many years since we've had dinner here. We forgot how good it really is! Best is the family style portions. Had the lamb ribs, the striped bass, and the fried calamari salad."

##4 Pizza in Town of East...

Details

#4 Pizza in Town of East Hampton

Left Hand Coffee

4.2

Online table booking

4.2

Online table booking

City: MONTAUK, 83 S Elmwood Ave, 11954, Montauk, US, MONTAUK, United States

"Hmmm.. interesting thoughts. Alright so ambiance 5/5. Outdoor seating cute 5/5. Staff was nice. There was a big line out the door. They let me taste test the macadamia milk cuz I never had it before, which, by the way, was delicious! Unfortunately wehave to give it 4 stars because they messed up our order pretty bad. I asked for iced coffee and got cold brew. We asked fordifferent sizes than what we got. My friend disliked her dirty chai so much that she threw it out. BUT, I was honestly prettyhappy with my coffee and the macadamia milk!! I also LOVED that they had a vegan coconut blueberry muffin option. I think I?dreally rather give this place 4.5 stars because I?d personally go back! Some of us were frustrated because of the order mistakesbut all in all I was happy! I?d give it a second try again! After all, now I like macadamia nut milk because of this place! Formore Long Island reviews, visit us on Instagram @andiamoadventure"

##7 Vegetarian in MONTAUK

Details

#7 Vegetarian in MONTAUK Cafés

Westlake Fish House

4.1

Online table booking

4.1

Online table booking

City: MONTAUK, Montauk, 352 Westlake Dr, 11954-5104, MONTAUK, United States

"Food: 4 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 5"

##3 Sushi in MONTAUK

Details

#3 Sushi in MONTAUK

The Surfside Inn

4.1

Online table booking

4.1

Online table booking

City: MONTAUK, 685 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, New York, 11954, United States, MONTAUK

"We visited for dinner after walking on the beach.Great location, very good service and food."

##9 Pizza in MONTAUK

Details

#9 Pizza in MONTAUK

Clam And Chowder House At Salivar's Dock

4.1

Online table booking

4.1

Online table booking

City: MONTAUK, 470 W Lake Dr, MONTAUK, United States

Terrace, Wheelchair Accessible, Parking, TV

##4 Sushi in MONTAUK

Details

#4 Sushi in MONTAUK

Scarpetta Beach

4.2

Online table booking

4.2

Online table booking

City: MONTAUK, 290 Old Montauk Highway Montauk, NY 11954, 11954-5048, MONTAUK, United States

"The food is amazing everytime I come here. Drinks by the fire pit on the water is the perfect vibe. Highly recommend Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

##3 Pizza in MONTAUK

Details

#3 Pizza in MONTAUK Seafood