Bagels 101 - Middle Island

#14 - Order Cafés Middle Island, #14 - Order Kebab Middle Island, Fast Food
852 Middle Country Road Middle Island, NY 11953, United States
Dishes: 70
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Bagels 101 852 Middle Country Road Middle Isla...
Phone
+16312059511
Reservation
Reservation request for Bagels 101.

Menu

The restaurant from Middle Island offers 70 different menus and drinks on the menu for an average price of $6.3.

Bagels 101 boasts a reputation for crafting traditional, boiled bagels that many local patrons rave about. Customers appreciate the quick service, diverse menu, and the quality of food, especially the egg sandwiches and bagel sandwiches. However, a growing concern arises regarding hygiene and customer service practices. Reports of rude staff interactions, poor hygiene, and incorrect orders have tarnished the dining experience for some loyal customers. While the food often delights, the inconsistency in service and cleanliness suggests that management needs to address staff behavior to truly elevate the restaurant's appeal. Overall, it remains a popular spot but requires improvements for a more satisfying experience.

Last update: 21.04.2025

Images

Bagels 101 food Bagels 101 food Bagels 101 drink

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 2.7 / 5 from 3 reviews

Was Mary at Bagels 101 a mag?
they always do a great BEC SPK. My boyfriend gets sauteed onions and provolone on his BEC. They always make perfect bagel sandwiches and toast bagels properly. Coffee is just fine. View all feedback.

What Karlie Hansen dislikes about Bagels 101:
I've been here bout 5times each time my order has never been right now I order today guy blows his nose and doesn't wash his hands I didn't want to make a seen so I payed 4it and thru it rite out in garbage he didn't catch the hint and then continued to serve food that's disgusting so people be careful when u eat here View all feedback.

gary-21
Gary 17.07.2023 - 10:15

I have now stopped at this bagel store a few times working out east when it's in the direction I'm heading. I've had bagels from here that have been very tasty, I've also had breakfast wraps as the last time I was there I had a sausage egg and mozzarella wrap. Came out in a timely fashion with a coffee to go and I was back on the road in less than 10 minutes. I will be back once again once I'm working in that direction.

lisa-24
Lisa 17.07.2023 - 10:15

Lisa I came in, they were very busy. But the order was Ready Jack! I breased in out like the wind The counter lady gave me the, You got it acknowledgement. And I was out, customer house bound! Way to Be 101! Yup yup! Way to be! p.s. note the order was on a separate counter, than the customer line. The pickup was So quick, like Lightning lol. So fast, I couldn't even take pics. Next time. Lisa Lichelle

mary-13
Mary 17.07.2023 - 10:15

They always do a great BEC SPK. My boyfriend gets sauteed onions and provolone on his BEC. They always make perfect bagel sandwiches and toast bagels properly. Coffee is just fine.

michael-562
Michael 17.07.2023 - 10:15

The absolute best place to get fresh and delicious bagels on Long Island!

jonathan-176
Jonathan 17.07.2023 - 10:15

Felicity was wonderful and her suggestions were absolutely delicious. I give this restaurant a perfect 5 out of 5 rating and will definitely return just to see her again! Thank you so much!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.