Madeline's - Ithaca Reviews (16)

So that you don't dive naively into a new culinary adventure, Menulist has compiled all the reviews for Madeline's - Ithaca from various websites, so you can get a transparent picture. So far there are 16 reviews found on 1 pages. On average, Madeline's - Ithaca was rated 3.6. This means that the vast majority of its guests was satisfied with its service. Help our community find the best spots and submit a review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

3.6 out of 5

Very good | 16 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Madeline's - Ithaca from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (3.6 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in Ithaca.

paucek-warren

21.04.2023 - 08:06

Server was snoring (for example, when he greeted our table when my guests arrived, he said how you are, and everyone said well. Well, thank you and he said than...

awilderman

21.04.2023 - 08:06

Although I live 350 miles away, Madeline is one of my favorite restaurants. I was thrilled to introduce this new one to them from the city friends and they enjo...

mable68

21.04.2023 - 08:06

Madeline's is fine dining at an affordable price. The service is very good and the desserts are absolutely amazing! Eating outside on the commons is a special t...

enrico-206

18.04.2022 - 14:16

We only stopped in to pick up some dessert (apparently a common tradition for college students), and they tasted good.

allan-480

10.04.2020 - 12:26

We have been to Madeline's before and had good food and service. The food was good but not great on our last visit. The apps were good but my Shepard's Pie was...

Last update : 21.04.2023

You need to register or login to leave feedback.

Good Rated Restaurants near Ithaca

Northeast Pizza And Bones

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: Ithaca, 23 Cinema Dr, 14850, Ithaca, US, United States

"Large pizza and wings. we had the special pizza. a little expensive, but very good."

##6 Pizza in Ithaca

Details

#6 Pizza in Ithaca American

U Tea

4.9

Online table booking

4.9

Online table booking

City: City of Ithaca (near Ithaca), 205 Dryden Rd, Ithaca, NY, 14580, 14850, City of Ithaca, United States

"This drink is very good, its also not too sweet and goes very well with the cheese"

##17 Cafés in City of Itha...

Details

#17 Cafés in City of Ithaca Coffee

Sumo Hibachi And Sushi

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Ithaca, 2309 N Triphammer Rd #15, Ithaca, United States

"The restaurant is modern and clean. The hibachi was subpar at best. The “soup” we got was literally just water with pepper and a couple scallions and dry mushrooms floating around. No miso in ithow do you forget the miso??? None of us could eat the soup. The salad was fine lettuce with a lot of weirdly chunky dressing. They gave us one dipping sauce that was boring tasted like mayo mixed with ketchup. The noodles and rice were just soy sauce and had little of anything else added to it no veggie mixed in the rice either. The portions were good, but it felt like I was cheated a bit for the $30 I paid for it. Very little theatrics from the hibachi chef, he wasn’t conversing with us. Just made the food, clanged his utensils, mocked something I said, and left. We got two bursts of fire and that was it. NOT worth coming for the hibachi. The sushi looks good in the other reviews but I’m not sold. Wouldn’t come back for the hibachi, that’s for sure. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 2 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 4"

##20 Sushi in Ithaca

Details

#20 Sushi in Ithaca

Italian Carry Out

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Ithaca, 1070 Danby Rd, 14850, Ithaca, United States

"Best food in Ithaca! Best pizza, salads, subs. Oh! and the blue cheese!"

##11 Pizza in Ithaca

Details

#11 Pizza in Ithaca Italian

Ciao Wood- Fired Pizza Pasta

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Ithaca, 2 Hickory Hollow Ln, 14850, Ithaca, United States

"I have lived in Ithaca for two years and this restaurant was the first time I felt I was a minority. My husband, daughter, and myself sat at our table for 20 min and no one took our order or bring us water. However, a white couple at the next table arrived later than us but ordered 15 minutes earlier than us. The waiters walked passed us multiple times yet they all ignored us. They wouldn’t take our order but took orders from people who arrived later than us. Many people who arrived later than us enjoyed their dinners earlier than we did, and we were the only ones waiting helplessly. We waved at the waiter, and they just told us “please wait,” but it seemed like we were the only ones who needed to wait. If you are not a majority, I strongly advise you not coming during peak hours."

##3 Pizza in Ithaca

Details

#3 Pizza in Ithaca Seafood Vegetarian

Gola Osteria

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Ithaca, 115 South Quarry StreetNY 14850, Ithaca, United States

"Outrageous food, poor service. Food was perfectly cooked. Wait staff were absent and didn’t listen."

##1 Pizza in Ithaca

Details

#1 Pizza in Ithaca Italian Bar-Lounge

Taste Of Thai

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Ithaca, 216 East State St (at The Commons), Ithaca, New York, USA, 14850, United States

"After prior review we did not ask vegan fish sauce or oils. We don't think we have any. But we asked for brown rice, and they gave us what questioned me how much we understood. Food tastes good."

##21 Sushi in Ithaca

Details

#21 Sushi in Ithaca

Mix Social Dining

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Ithaca, 205 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, New York, USA, 14850, United States

"Sourdough French toast with bananas and cinnamon was delicious."

##2 European in Ithaca

Details

#2 European in Ithaca European

Glenwood Pines

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Ithaca, 1213 Taughannock Blvd, 14850, Ithaca, United States

"Once a cozy , friendly place I often went to for decades.This time I asked for a table for myself and two visitors. The guy at the counter rudely said the menu is on the wall, order and pick up here . Can we sit downstairs? The menu is on the wall, order and pick up here . Turns out there is no longer waitstaff, you find or share a table, everything is plastic (utensils, cups, dinner boxes), the salad is soggy and dressing terrible, the food not close to its previous incarnation and they don 't even inform you when your order in the plastic bag is ready. I was embarrassed I took friends there and will never return. The only good thing at this fast food location was that they didn 't ask if everything was O.K. I miss the Pines! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 3 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1 Parking space: Plenty of parking Parking options Free parking lot"

##16 Seafood in Ithaca

Details

#16 Seafood in Ithaca