Dark Horse - Findlay

American, Barbecue, Delivery Services
4136 N Main St Findlay, OH 45840-7215, United States
Dishes: 38
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Dark Horse 4136 N Main St Findlay, OH 45840-72...
Phone
+14194249201
Reservation
Reservation request for Dark Horse.

Menu

On this site, you will find the complete menu of Dark Horse from Findlay. Currently, there are 38 dishes and drinks available.

The Dark Horse restaurant offers a diverse menu with something for everyone. Despite some reviews criticizing the service, the food quality and prices seem to be consistent highlights. Customers raved about the prime rib special, steak, burgers, and salads. The house made blue cheese dressing received particular praise. While some guests felt the service was lacking, others appreciated their friendly and efficient waitstaff like Amy and Princesses J. Overall, the Dark Horse seems to be a hidden gem worth stopping by for a meal, especially if you are in the Finley area.

Last update: 20.04.2025

Images

Dark Horse food Dark Horse inside Dark Horse food Dark Horse food Dark Horse food Dark Horse food Dark Horse inside Dark Horse food Dark Horse food Dark Horse food

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 2265 reviews

Was Dee P at Dark Horse a mag?
What can I say! I LOVE finding hidden gems and this was 1 of them! Fun atmosphere for family or a night out! The bartender Princesses J...I believe was a hoot and made you feel completely at home! I was lucky enough to be there when they had the prime rib special and let me tell you it was spot on! YUMMY! The salad was amazing as well! I did take-out and had a cocktail while waiting...they. were good as well! I've al... View all feedback.

What Brandon Kristofer Pinco Cabanillas dislikes about Dark Horse:
Very rude staff,no respect at all,food is ok,but I recommend no one work their.....Money per hour sucks,this is 2024,not the early 2000s.plus the prices their are really expensive, been going their every Sunday since I was 12.not anymore,plus when it comes to the hosts,they suck because when I walk in,they have no one their. View all feedback.

heather-queenie
Heather 21.09.2023 - 14:40

If you are in the area or passing through this is a definite stop! Looks small from outside but there is plenty of seating. We had come from Jeffery's Antique indoor flea market on the same exit (161) The food was all really good, service good wait for food was good/as expected. Our table ordered: Fried Mushrooms (ranch/horseradish sauces) Wings (ordered to go, crispy) Hatch burger with homemade chips pickle 8 oz Sirloin with scalloped potatoes dark horse salad The steak was a pleasant surprise. I was a little worried about ordering steak but it was really good. The seasoning cook was perfect for me. The salad was also really good. It had a radish slice, half an egg, croutons bacon. I added onion to mine. The chips were homemade nicely seasoned. The wings we got to go ordered crispy and haven't tried but they smelled fantastic. There is a great variety on menu. Something for everyone

michael-koehler-1
Michael 21.09.2023 - 14:40

Just passing through... Really the place is Awesome. We were traveling over the holidays and came across the Dark Horse. It was a little off the beaten path and the building is not fancy but the food and service were outstanding. I had the mushroom burger with onion rings which was worth ordering again. Baby girl had the bacon cheeseburger with fries and she loved it the burgers are thick and prepared well Wifie had the club sandwich with a side salad. The club sandwich was really good but the side salad was great their blue cheese dressing is fantastic... The Dark Horse is worth stopping by for a meal when in the Finley area.

dee-p-2
Dee 21.09.2023 - 14:40

What can I say! I LOVE finding hidden gems and this was 1 of them! Fun atmosphere for family or a night out! The bartender Princesses J...I believe was a hoot and made you feel completely at home! I was lucky enough to be there when they had the prime rib special and let me tell you it was spot on! YUMMY! The salad was amazing as well! I did take-out and had a cocktail while waiting...they. were good as well! I've already recommended it to 2 different people and I encourage you to stop if in the area!

rachel-meinke
Rachel 21.09.2023 - 14:40

WOW! this is an incredible place to eat! It doesn't look like much from the outside, but you can tell the kitchen and wait staff know what they are doing here! Had great service and great food! A friend of mine asked for a specialty salad and it was no problem along with being delicious! Their house made blue cheese dressing is out of this world.... I can't say enough good things! Their prices were really good too, especially for the quality! I ordered a blackened burger with blue cheese and house cut fries. I believe it was 8.99, which was definitely worth every penny! Along with the great food, their service was great! This place was full when we went there, but you'd never notice from the timely staff! Definitely going to be a repeat customer!

kim-morse-1
Kim 21.09.2023 - 14:40

Food and drinks are the best! Had a great waitress, Amy, who kept her cool even tho the restaurant was clearly under staffed! Customers just need to be kind and patient!.... just had breakfast here.. definately not out first time.. the breakfast foods outstanding.. you get SO MUCH for your money! Cheapest and most delicious in town! And Amy, our server, we love her! She's quick, gets it right and super friendly!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.