Colony Pub & Grill - Erie

Pubs, Steak, Fish
2670 W 8th St Erie, PA 16505-4021, United States
Dishes: 33
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Colony Pub & Grill 2670 W 8th St Erie, PA 16505-4021,...
Phone
+18148382162
+18148367600
Reservation
Reservation request for Colony Pub & Grill.

Menu

The menu of Colony Pub & Grill from Erie includes 33 courses. On average the courses or drinks on the menu cost approximately $14.1. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Colony Pizza has garnered a mix of passionate opinions from its loyal patrons. While some customers express disappointment regarding delivery issues and order inaccuracies, others rave about the exceptional quality of the pizza and the warm, friendly service. Diners appreciate the thin crust, flavorful toppings, and the unique gyro ball. The owner, Eric, is often highlighted for his attentive customer care, creating a welcoming atmosphere. Overall, while challenges exist, many believe Colony Pizza remains a top choice in town, thanks to its delicious offerings and dedicated staff. For pizza enthusiasts, it's worth a visit—or a second chance.

Last update: 22.05.2025

Images

Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food Colony Pub & Grill food

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 174 reviews

Was Jeanne P at Colony Pub & Grill a mag?
We had lunch today at the Colony, and it was fantastic. The Cobb salad with French dressing was absolutely delightful, and as always, the French onion soup was amazing! View all feedback.

What Bob H dislikes about Colony Pub & Grill:
I have been enjoying meals at The Colony for many years, and it truly disappoints me to see the decline in food quality. Unfortunately, tonight was no exception. The chicken was... View all feedback.

margaret58
Margaret 15.04.2020 - 09:07

We decided to support our local restaurants and chose the fish special at The Colony.

lincoln-grant
Lincoln 15.04.2020 - 09:07

It was my birthday and first time to The Colony Pub and Grille It was a great experience.

nannie22
Nannie 17.06.2022 - 12:37

I found the best pizza in town. it is the thin crust and the little paprika he loves. the taste is great! pizzelles are also the best in the city. Thanks for making pizza again!

angelika78
Angelika 17.06.2022 - 12:37

Ordered from here for the first time tonight and they were absolutely amazing! First there was a mix up with my order and they were very apologetic and remade my order also let me keep the pizza that was incorrect. When they brought the correct pizza to my car they also brought me some cookies and apologized once again! The customer service was outstanding and then the food itself was outstanding! I will definitely be ordering again and encourage others to try them as well!!!

tristan-zimms-1
Tristan 27.12.2023 - 14:43

The gyro ball is awesome and the pizza was fantastic and there 's Pens plaques all over the walls... what 's not to love! Who the heck wants NY style when you can have PA Perfection Pizza... I 'll be visiting here again real soon ???

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.