Cappy's Northside Tavern - Elkhart

#19 - Mexican - Elkhart, #24 - Cafés - Elkhart, Sushi
1000 N Michigan St Elkhart, IN 46514-2214, United States
Dishes: 29
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Cappy's Northside Ta... 1000 N Michigan St Elkhart, IN 4651...
Phone
+15742623511
Reservation
Reservation request for Cappy's Northside Ta....

Menu

A complete menu of Cappy's Northside Tavern from Elkhart featuring all 29 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Cappy's, a long-time local favorite, has faced challenges with new ownership resulting in changes to the menu and food quality. Despite this, the casual atmosphere and friendly staff remain a draw for many. The portions and value for money are praised, with favorites like the white chicken chili and tenderloin receiving high marks. While some have experienced inconsistency and issues like cold food, others have found Cappy's to be a unique and special spot with delicious offerings. Overall, Cappy's continues to be a neighborhood staple, blending comfort food with friendly service at an affordable price point.

Last update: 20.04.2025

Images

Cappy's Northside Tavern food Cappy's Northside Tavern food Cappy's Northside Tavern food Cappy's Northside Tavern food

Reservation request for Cappy's Northside Tavern

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 1655 reviews

Was Michael St at Cappy's Northside Tavern a mag?
This is an old place, with a lot of history and has never been updated. It will take you back in time and the average customer is definitely on social security! But the food is all made there and it really was excellent. Prices are low and the service is pretty good. I will go back. View all feedback.

What Don Camillo dislikes about Cappy's Northside Tavern:
Not the same since ownership change. Not the same standard of service. Disappointing. Salads served with entree. Food was cold. Mostaccioli with sausage for $16 had two small pieces of sausage. When asked about the lack of sausage I was told that’s how it is portioned. Check brought during the meal. Plates not cleared. We will not return. View all feedback.

jay-kneifel-3
Jay 05.10.2024 - 13:44

I just stopped by for the first time in 27 years and the food is still just as delicious! It’s nice to see that they have taken great care of the place while keeping its original things like the bar that give is such character.

cindy-vanderwerf-1
Cindy 05.10.2024 - 13:44

We had a great experience from the time we entered the door. The food was delicious! The whole dinner was wonderful.

luke-ben
Luke 05.10.2024 - 13:44

The server didn't seem to care about us at all. Even after we pulled a hair out of the marinara right in front of her! Burntttt bacon on my bacon cheeseburger (which was dryer than my sense of humor). Had to have another server get our bill at the end. Sad story.

marilyn-nash-grass63
Marilyn 05.10.2024 - 13:44

Delicious food, great atmosphere and friendly service!

becky-wiese-lawyer3
Becky 05.10.2024 - 13:44

Love this local gem. My favorite menu item is the white chicken chili. It was a bit runny with very little chicken or beans last time we had it to go. Hoping that was just an off day. Deep fried tenderloin is also fantastic.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.