The Eagle Short North - Feedback

#28 - Order Seafood Columbus, American, Sandwiches
790 N High St Columbus, OH 43215, 43215-1553, United States
Dishes: 89

Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.6 out of 5
Outstanding | 17031 reviews

Reviews from various websites

Menu
4.8 ★ from 53 reviews
yquitzon
Donato 30.11.2022 - 11:22

Eating was amazing, and tyler was one of the best servers we ever had! he made the food even better!

garrick-sauer
Garrick 30.11.2022 - 11:22

If they love and want the best fried chicken and tasteful beside dishes ever this their place. recommend the meerrettich kartoffeln, and chic cornbread absolutely delicious. we chose this restaurant by reading other reviews, the reviews were completely on the brand. we live about 35 to 40 minutes from here, we come back. If you love chicken, you have to come here.

jameson-51
Jameson 09.10.2021 - 01:42

We love this place. Food is always consistently great.

hking-1
Maximillia 30.11.2022 - 11:22

We enjoyed our food and service was excellent and friendly. The only downside was how loud the girls sitting next to us (on the other side of the booth partition) were…we literally couldn’t hear ourselves think, let alone have a conversation!

jeramy77
Jeramy 30.11.2022 - 11:22

Excellent food, service , and bartender made good drinks. Can’t wait to come back .

Last update: 30.11.2022

Located in the lively Short North District, this restaurant offers a mix of experiences for diners. While some guests may find the noise level a bit high and the prices a tad steep, the food is generally good with some standout dishes like the steamed shrimp and Southern Chopped salad. The outdoor seating area is a nice touch, especially for those looking to enjoy a meal by the water. Despite some service mishaps and inconsistencies in dishes like the Chicken BLT or the 1/2 Chicken, there are still plenty of highlights to be found, such as the Carolina Braised Pork, Hush Puppies, and Mac and Cheese, all of which have left customers eagerly anticipating their next visit. Overall, The Eagle offers a warm and friendly atmosphere with generous portions of flavorful food that will likely keep guests coming back for more.

Opentable
4.8 ★ from 517 reviews
elisa
Elisa 20.09.2024 - 17:10

Food was amazing definitely get their chicken. Cocktails were amazing as well. Server came around often to put in drink orders and helped the experience go smoothly. Food came out within minutes and it was fresh and amazing. Only thing is with outdoor seating there is lots of bees because of flower pots. Would recommend sitting inside!

gennifer
Gennifer 20.09.2024 - 17:10

This place has the best mac n cheese and hush puppies I’ve ever had! Outstanding food, beer, service, and chill environment!

latasha
LaTasha 20.09.2024 - 17:10

The chicken BLT was delicious and I love the seasoning on the fries. The kids enjoyed the chicken with hot honey. The waiter did amazing for his first day out of training. The Eagle never disappoints!

flame
Flame 20.09.2024 - 17:10

We had great time .. food is always good, servis was great ..Manager Chris was so nice and friendly ..our server Ryan was great ..

heidi
Heidi 20.09.2024 - 17:10

Service was outstanding. The chicken was not crispy and my husband and I both got sick within a couple of hours leaving the restaurant.

Last update: 20.09.2024
Restaurantji
4.5 ★ from 501 reviews
maria-6039
Maria 16.08.2023 - 05:25

Food was delicious! I’m very picky with my greens and the ones I had here were so delicious! I also really enjoyed the sweet potatoes and the cornbread. The only small thing is didn’t like was that our chicken was extremely small. But besides that, everything exceeded our expectations.Food: 5/5

lwhitt
LWhitt 16.08.2023 - 05:25

This was our first time here. We decided to try it after several people suggested it. It was great! We got both the chicken sandwich and the white meat 1/4 chicken. We also had the hush puppies and fries. It was all so yummy! Also we had anm service. Our waiter Jakob was great, and management also stopped by quickly to check on us.

sledner
Shawn 16.08.2023 - 05:25

The food and service was so amazing ! I have a dairy allergy and our sweet server took such great care of me !! We got the chicken blt, succotash, fries and Aoili , and Mac and cheese. We highly recommend them all!

opentable-3
OpenTable 16.08.2023 - 05:25

We had a great server, and the food, as always, was good. Bring back the shrimp po’boys!

van-wuckert
Van 16.08.2023 - 05:25

Came here because we have been looking for some good southern food. So glad we did. First off, our server Ethan was awesome! He made us feel welcome. My wife ordered the BLT and it was spectacular. I had the 1/4 dark chicken and it was really good. The honey hot sauce compliments perfectly. It is slightly sweet, spicy and vinegary. We also ordered the collard greens which were to die for. The smashed potatoes had a nice spice to them and the biscuits were delicious. A great experience and we will be back for sure.

Last update: 16.08.2023
Aggregated
5.0 ★ from 10 reviews
ewiza
Ian 11.06.2023 - 13:41

Good food. huh, mac and cheese and sweet potato was great. fries and aioli were also tasted. good times and employees are friendly.

fnieto
Silvia 11.06.2023 - 13:41

Amazing mac and cheese. corn brot and fried chicken were also quite good. reservations recommended (and explicitly mention when they wish to sit in free).

angel04
Angel 11.06.2023 - 13:41

I ordered the orange chicken lunch special, and it was pretty good. I drove home about 5 minutes and opened it, and the chicken was still crispy. I like it that they roast it deeply, so that it remains crispy even after a few minutes in a pull-out container. ...

asd-lsby
أسعد 11.06.2023 - 13:41

Loved it ! Thank you for saving our night after hubbarts

carmel-bailey
Carmel 11.06.2023 - 13:41

I don’t think I’ve ever rated a restaurant on google... but I am inspired to do so. Maybe the best sandwich I’ve ever had, friendly staff, and COVID-19 friendly outside space (the places around the block from there cannot say the same). Can’t wait to go back again!

Last update: 11.06.2023
Int Restaurants
4.3 ★ from 7470 reviews
phil-115
Phil 20.07.2023 - 17:32

Food was really good. The chicken is some of the best I've had. Fries, mac and cheese and mashed potatoes were great as well. The jalepeno mayo is Ask for Collin. He is awesome! Very informative and made sure we were well taken care of.

sharon-231
Sharon 20.07.2023 - 17:32

A lively place in the city's Short North District that has great food and great atmosphere. Enjoyed the chicken sandwich and my friend had the chicken club! Very tasty, juicy, chicken and the portions are nice-sized. They have an outdoor dining area that looks inviting. It was a bit cold to eat out when we went. Looking forward to going back to enjoy the patio!

steve-465
Steve 20.07.2023 - 17:32

Actually stumbled upon the Eagle after leaving Lincoln Social and walking around the short north with the misses, we were hungry and this place hit the spot. Thenchicken was seasoned wonderfully, the collards were delicious, the mac and cheese wasn't my favorite but got much better as the sauce settled. We had a pitcher of the blackberry lemonade which hit the spot but not too much to get you drunk. We will definitely visit again. The hot honey was a pleasant surprise and bonus points for having Crystal's hot sauce which the misses loved as a west coast patron

cory-2
cory 20.07.2023 - 17:32

Off the main road with outside seating you have this amazing fried chicken place. Since I was alone I decided to sit at the bar and order food. It was a very quiet Sunday. The bar tender was very attentive and provided recommendations. I had the French fries (dining sauce is amazing). The fried chicken sandwich which was a nice size full of flavor and that spicy mayo packs the extra kick. My only suggestion is to toast the bread for that extra texture. The corn bread skillet, honestly don't remember what they called it but it was out of this world. I would highly recommend this place and will be back!!

joshua-233
Joshua 20.07.2023 - 17:32

A fantastic southern comfort food spot, the eagle is fantastic. Simple menu with lots of fun options and delicious food. Below I got the fried chicken sandwich with a side of succotash, both fantastic. We ordered hush puppies for the table and the spoon bread which I highly recommend. Overall great late night spot to eat or drink, would recommend to anybody.

Last update: 20.07.2023
Doordash
4.7 ★ from 7300 reviews
geion-c
Geion 25.11.2023 - 00:18

Good quality but the bread is soggy upon delivry. The chicken drum sticks are 10/10!!

steven-u-elephant5
Steven 25.11.2023 - 00:18

I ordered the Chicken BLT sandwich. The bread had a buttery/greasy texture, but it wasn't toasted or grilled, so it ended up completely soggy. However, I was able to salvage the chicken and enjoy that. The mashed potatoes were delicious.

daniel-m-library1
Daniel 25.11.2023 - 00:18

The 1/2 chicken did not come with the hot honey as described and was soggy and oily, so I do not recommend it. I also gave the horseradish mashed potatoes a try, but they were not to my liking. The best part of my order was the Southern Chopped (Full) dish.

maxwell-k-2
Maxwell 25.11.2023 - 00:18

The food at this restaurant was extremely overcooked and dry, making it as dry as hell. The sauce had an acceptable level of heat, but the balance of sweet and sour flavors was off-putting. The mac and cheese was almost good, but the cheese was too watery and had a predominant flour taste. The cornbread was incredibly dry, with an okay flavor that could potentially make you choke.

emily-w-lawyer0194
Emily 25.11.2023 - 00:18

The CAROLINA BRAISED PORK was excellent, Carolina gold bbq is mustard and vinegar based and not sweet like honey bbq. The bun was buttered and so so good. The HUSH PUPPIES were fabulous and the Mac and MAC CHEESE was some of the best white cheddar Mac I've ever had!!!

Last update: 25.11.2023
Sirved
4.3 ★ from 1180 reviews

Everything here tasted awesome! especially loved the spicy chicken dip and the Mac and cheese (no surprises there lol). Matthew our server was super nice and accommodating to our group. Recommend this place for sure!

Hubby and I LOVEEE eating here! The food never disappoints. We always share a whole chicken and 2-3 sides! The biscuits are delicious, especially with the jam and butter. He’s a big fan of the Mac and cheese, to me it’s just eh! We also love thecornbread and sometimes we get the fries depending on our mood(but usually not you can get fries anywhere)!! Repeat customersfor life.

A lively place in the city's Short North District that has great food and great atmosphere. Enjoyed the chicken sandwich and my friend had the chicken club! Very tasty, juicy, chicken and the portions are nice-sized. They have an outdoor dining area thatlooks inviting. It was a bit cold to eat out when we went. Looking forward to going back to enjoy the patio!

hyman-botsford
Hyman 25.05.2025 - 13:42

Actually stumbled upon the Eagle after leaving Lincoln Social and walking around the short north with the misses, we were hungry and this place hit the spot. Thenchicken was seasoned wonderfully, the collards were delicious, the mac and cheese wasn't myfavorite but got much better as the sauce settled. We had a pitcher of the blackberry lemonade which hit the spot but not toomuch to get you drunk. We will definitely visit again. The hot honey was a pleasant surprise and bonus points for havingCrystal's hot sauce which the misses loved as a west coast patron ????

hyman-botsford
Hyman 25.05.2025 - 13:42

I ordered the 1/4th chicken dark meat, Mac and cheese, and the sweet potato crock. The chicken could have used a little more seasoning. I was cooked to perfection though. That hot honey sauce is a amazing! The Mac and cheese was really great. Cheesy!The sweet potato crock was not my favorite. The sweet potato didn't taste very well without the marshmallow topping. Or rathertoo plain. It needed some butter, cinnamon, nutmeg something. A manager or supervisor Travis came over there and he noticed thatI only ate a little bit of it so he gave me little app vouchers for the next time I was in town since I already paid my bill. Myserver Zack was polite, prompt, and very attentive. Can't wait to go back and try other items.

Last update: 25.05.2025

Good Rated Restaurants near Columbus