Nicola's - Cincinnati

Italian, Pasta, Meat
1420 Sycamore Street Cincinnati, OH 45202, 45202-7631, United States
Dishes: 301
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Nicola's 1420 Sycamore Street Cincinnati, OH...
Phone
+15137216200
Reservation
Reservation request for Nicola's.

Menu

The menu of Nicola's from Cincinnati comprises about 301 different courses and drinks. On average you pay about $97.1 for a dish / drink.

The restaurant received mostly positive reviews, with customers praising the delicious food, great atmosphere, and attentive service. The menu was described as innovative and the dishes were flavorful and well-balanced. Some highlights included the leg of lamb with saffron rice, beef kofta kabob, and mini chocolate cake. Customers also appreciated the relaxed and romantic atmosphere, as well as the recommendations from the servers. However, there was one negative review that detailed a disappointing experience in Cincinnati, with cold and unappetizing food, rude service, and unprofessional behavior from the manager. Despite this, overall feedback for the restaurant was positive, with many customers planning to return in the future and recommending it to friends.

Last update: 17.04.2025

Images

Nicola's food Nicola's food Nicola's food Nicola's food Nicola's food Nicola's food Nicola's food Nicola's food Nicola's menu Nicola's outside

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 9513 reviews

Was Freya Fisch at Nicola's a mag?
It was my birthday, but our delayed flight made us arrive late in Cincinnati; still, Nicola's welcomed us and didn't rush us through our meal even though we got there within 45 minutes of closing time. They doted on us. I forgot to mention the food (absolutely delicious from appetizer to dessert) and our server, Kristen (top notch), and that night's manage, Ben (who shared old Cincinnati stories with me and suggested... View all feedback.

What Stacey Hughes dislikes about Nicola's:
Let me start by giving a hats off to the amazing chef and staff at Nicola's, for making my wife's birthday a memorable one. The flavor and presentation of the food was second to none. The four of us had various amazing dishes but the standouts were the mushroom Gnudi, little ravioli, minus the pasta, served with a mushroom broth I had to soak up with the bread. The Belgian endive salad is an amazing creation both vis... View all feedback.

wendy-k-flower76
Wendy 13.01.2024 - 15:32

The ambiance, food, and customer service were exceptional. It was our second time dining at this restaurant, which has been in business for 27 years. I am already eagerly anticipating our next meal there. I found...

kim-s-lawyer8
Kim 13.01.2024 - 15:32

We had a great dining experience at a luxurious restaurant located in a historic barn that once housed Cincinnati's 19th century incline trolleys. The food was delicious and the service from the staff was exceptional. We...

melanie-u-fish5702
Melanie 13.01.2024 - 15:32

You must try the bread basket at Nicola's! I have eaten here twice and absolutely love their bolognese and gnocchi dishes. The restaurant has a lovely and upscale Italian ambience.

willie-parker-4
Willie 14.10.2024 - 04:31

We had an amazing dinner. The food and service was outstanding. The atmosphere was very quaint and not too loud like many restaurants these days. My wife and I celebrated our 19th anniversary shh dinner there tonight. The special printing on the menus and hospitality was amazing.

janet-jansen-1
Janet 14.10.2024 - 04:31

Nicola’s always wows! Our meal last night was delicious and the service is superior. My favorite Cincinnati restaurant

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.