Sal's Pizza - Carmel

Pizza, Chicken, Sandwiches
1885 Route 6 Carmel, NY 10512, United States
Dishes: 19
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Sal's Pizza 1885 Route 6 Carmel, NY 10512, Unite...
Phone
+18452255454
Reservation
Reservation request for Sal's Pizza.

Menu

Here you will find the menu of Sal's Pizza in Carmel. At the moment, there are 19 dishes and drinks on the menu.

Sal's Pizza, located in the charming Carmel Hamlet, NY, is a beloved American eatery that boasts an impressive 4.1-star average rating. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, this welcoming spot is perfect for families, making it a great choice for dining with kids. Interested in finding out how busy it gets or reserving a table? Feel free to call them at (845) 225-5454. If you're looking for similar dining experiences, be sure to check out KFC and New Pagoda Kitchen Inc as well. Have you had the pleasure of dining at Sal's Pizza? We encourage you to share your thoughts and leave a review!.

Last update: 10.06.2025

Images

Sal's Pizza food Sal's Pizza food Sal's Pizza food Sal's Pizza food Sal's Pizza menu Sal's Pizza food Sal's Pizza food Sal's Pizza food Sal's Pizza inside Sal's Pizza menu

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 480 reviews

Was User at Sal's Pizza a mag?
We ordered the Chicken Parm Pasta dinner for two, and it was fantastic! It came with bread and salad, and her house dressing is amazing. There were plenty of leftovers! View all feedback.

What User dislikes about Sal's Pizza:
Worst food and most rude service imaginable! Pizza was cold, had to ask for it to be heated twice. Meatballs are NOT homemade, they?re the commercial frozen kind with fillers. Fried zucchini was burnt. Girl behind the counter was super rude! Asked if we wanted the food we couldn?t eat (99% of it) boxed and we told her no, it was horrible. She snapped back ?I didn?t ask how it was!? Do yourself and your stomach a favo... View all feedback.

elmer-119
Elmer 03.03.2020 - 08:53

Love this place. I always go out of my way to stop in when I am in Fishkill. My favorite is the lasagna slice. Very generous with the toppings on this one.

catalina17
Catalina 21.12.2017 - 12:31

There are a variety of ready made pizzas in the display caseHad a plain slice, it wasn't the size of a catcher's mitt.

alek-farrell
Alek 21.12.2017 - 12:31

Really enjoyed Sals pizza. Also enjoyed their chicken sorrentino and eggplant rollatini dinners. Very good salads too! Better than Antonellas pizza and food.

forest-wilkinson
Forest 02.05.2023 - 09:23

The evaluation of Christine Stone is wrong. Unfortunately, I was a witness to her “Karen” show during my family and I just tried to enjoy our delicious meal of Sal’s that NIE lets us down. I'm an advocate for good business. Sal is never disappointed and if something is accidentally grounded, they will immediately replace it or offer a loan in the future. I've been a customer for 20 years. Of course, they will not accept the respectless customers who shout at the young counter-workers, that is the only reason why I can't replace this business or see credits their FRESH food.

siegl-sophia
Sophia 02.05.2023 - 09:23

This place is great and the meatballs are 100% homemade You can observe that they please remember that this place and all other small businesses are people living, be respectful or do yourself and all others a favor and stay at home!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.