Tocolo Cantina - CARLE PLACE

#5 - Order Mexican CARLE PLACE, Cafés, Asiatic
920 Old Country Road Garden City, NY 11530, 11514-2128, CARLE PLACE, United States
Dishes: 650
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Address
Tocolo Cantina 920 Old Country Road Garden City, NY...
Phone
+15162220060
Reservation
Reservation request for Tocolo Cantina.

Menu

The restaurant from CARLE PLACE offers 650 different dishes and drinks on the menu at an average price of $14.5.

Overall, the restaurant received mixed reviews from patrons. While some appreciated the good service and delicious food, others were disappointed with various aspects such as watered-down drinks, lackluster food, and loud atmosphere. Some diners praised the outstanding fajitas and original drinks, along with the friendly and knowledgeable staff. However, there were also complaints about slow and rude service, mediocre food, and overpriced items on the menu. Despite the mixed feedback, the establishment seems to have loyal customers who enjoy the pleasant atmosphere and great service provided, making it a decent option for those seeking a Mexican meal.

Last update: 14.07.2025

Images

Tocolo Cantina inside Tocolo Cantina food Tocolo Cantina food Tocolo Cantina food Tocolo Cantina food Tocolo Cantina food Tocolo Cantina food

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 1218 reviews

Was Alexander von Daake at Tocolo Cantina a mag?
The service because mainly of Andy is what brings us back to Tocolo Cantina. He is a real asset to your company. The food is very good; especially the tortilla soup which is something everyone must try. View all feedback.

What MeganW dislikes about Tocolo Cantina:
The food was okay. For $31 I would have liked more than 6 shrimp with my fajitas. The tortillas were super chewy . My daughter had the chicken tinga enchilada and it was okay. More like a $15 meal vs $25. Nothing over the top. What was over the top was the Classico Guacamole which was amazing. And the service and staff were fantastic. I needed a plate for my fajitas and was looking around for my server, and another s... View all feedback.

karen
Karen 22.10.2024 - 04:18

Excellent $19 lunch special Guacamole and chips Mexican salad-enough for 2 Soda I took 1/2 home for tomorrow

alexander
Alexander 22.10.2024 - 04:18

Your wait staff is exceptional, especially Andy Phoebe. The service they provide is what brings us back to dine. They are assets to your company.

alexander
Alexander 22.10.2024 - 04:18

Always a pleasure to dine and enjoy the friendly atmosphere. Try it you'll like it!

frank
Frank 22.10.2024 - 04:18

Chips salsa guac plantains and yuca were excellent. Tacos were dry Veggie bowl was decent Drinks were all ice

alexander
Alexander 22.10.2024 - 04:18

The service because mainly of Andy is what brings us back to Tocolo Cantina. He is a real asset to your company. The food is very good; especially the tortilla soup which is something everyone must try.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.